Last week, the Office for Civil Rights (“OCR”) announced a settlement with Lafourche Medical Group (“LMG”), a Louisiana medical group, for a 2021 phishing attack and breach that affected the protected health information (“PHI”) of 34,862 individuals. In addition to paying $480,000 to OCR, LMG agreed to a corrective action plan that will include implementing security measures to protect electronic PHI, developing written policies and procedures to comply with HIPAA rules, and training staff members.

Continue Reading OCR Takes Enforcement Action for Phishing Attack

On August 18, 2023, the World Bank issued a publication entitled, “Digital-in-Health: Unlocking the Value for Everyone (“World Bank Report”),” which recommends to governments a new digital-in-health approach where digital technology and data are infused into every aspect of health systems management and health service delivery to improve individuals’ health outcomes. The stated goal of the World Bank Report is to provide governments and other stakeholders with practical guidance on how to build digital health infrastructure, regardless of a country’s digital maturity or fiscal challenges.

Continue Reading World Bank Issues Digital Health Recommendations in Report

On November 8, 2023, the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee Subcommittee on Primary Health and Retirement Security discussed the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) on the healthcare sector in the Committee’s second AI hearing in nine days. The hearing comes as the White House and Congressional leaders seek to quickly respond to AI threats, mitigate its dangers, and harness its potential for American industry. Senators discussed the recent Executive Order issued by the White House to guide AI regulation and innovation across all sectors, including in the health and human services sectors.

Continue Reading Avoiding a Cautionary Tale: Policy Considerations for Artificial Intelligence in Health Care

On October 11, the National Institutes of Health (“NIH”) issued a request for information (“RFI”), which proposes sample language regarding the use of digital health technologies in research for inclusion in informed consent documents and requests public feedback on the utility and usability of the proposed language. Comments on the RFI are due by December 12, 2023.

Continue Reading NIH Requests Information on Developing Consent Language for Research Using Digital Health Technologies

On October 30, President Joe Biden signed an Executive Order (“EO”) 14110 entitled the, “Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Development and Use of Artificial Intelligence,” which establishes a policy framework to manage the risks of artificial intelligence (“AI”); to direct agency action to regulate the use of health AI systems and tools; and to guide AI innovation across all sectors, including in the health and human services sectors.

The EO outlines eight guiding principles and priorities to advance and govern the use of AI: (i) ensure safe and secure AI technology; (ii) promote responsible innovation, competition, and collaboration; (iii) support American workers; (iv) advance equity and civil rights; (v) protect American consumers, patients, passengers, and students; (vi) protect privacy and civil liberties; (vii) manage the federal government’s use of AI; and (viii) strengthen U.S. leadership abroad, safeguarding ways to develop and deploy AI technology responsibly.

The EO encourages independent federal agencies to leverage their current authorities and impose current applicable requirements to protect Americans from fraud, discrimination, threats to privacy, and other risks arising from AI in the health and human services, education, transportation and communication sectors. The EO contains a number of provisions aimed at the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”) to develop policies on the use of AI in health care. These policies will build on existing HHS efforts by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (“FDA”) and Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (“ONC”) related to the use of AI in the health and human sector, but will provide a more comprehensive approach beyond their current jurisdictions. For example, we will likely see guidance regarding nondiscrimination and privacy of health data related to AI and patient safety reporting.

In addition, the Biden Administration stated it will work with Congress as it continues to develop legislation on AI. The Administration also highlighted the importance of protecting individuals’ privacy when deploying AI tools and technologies and calls on Congress to pass comprehensive data privacy legislation.

This summary focuses on the EO’s health and human sector provisions, but the EO covers policies to govern AI generally and includes provisions that have multi-sector impact, including health care. (Crowell’s client alert provides a summary of all of the EO’s provisions.) Specifically, the EO directs the Secretary of HHS as follows:

  • Establish an HHS AI Task Force and develop a Strategic Plan on responsible deployment of AI by January 27, 2025 in the health and human services sector, including in the following areas:
    • development, maintenance, and use of predictive and generative AI-enabled technologies in health care delivery;
    • long-term safety and real-world performance monitoring of AI-enabled technologies;
    • incorporation of equity principles in AI-enabled technologies used in the health and human services sector, including protecting against bias;
    • incorporation of safety, privacy, and security standards into the software-development lifecycle for protection of personally identifiable information;
    • development and availability of documentation to help users determine appropriate and safe uses of AI in local settings;
    • work with state, local, tribal, and territorial health and human services agencies to advance positive use cases and best practices for use of AI in local settings; and
    • identifying uses of AI to promote workplace efficiency and satisfaction.
  • Develop a quality strategy by April 27, 2024 to determine whether AI-enabled technologies in the health and human services sector maintain appropriate levels of quality, including in the areas described above. This work would include the development of AI assurance policy and infrastructure needs for enabling premarket assessment and post-market oversight of AI-enabled health care technology algorithmic system performance against real-world data.
  • Advance nondiscrimination compliance by April 27, 2024 by considering appropriate actions to advance the prompt understanding of and compliance with federal nondiscrimination laws by health and human service providers that receive federal financial assistance, as well as how those laws relate to AI. These include convening and providing technical assistance about the obligations and the potential consequences of noncompliance with federal nondiscrimination and privacy laws as they relate to AI; and issuing guidance, or taking other action as appropriate, in response to any complaints or other reports of noncompliance.
  • Establish an AI Safety Program by October 29, 2024 that, in partnership with voluntary federally listed patient safety organizations (“PSOs”) establishes a common framework for approaches to identifying and capturing clinical errors resulting from AI deployed in health care settings as well as specifications for a central tracking repository for associated incidents that cause harm to patients, caregivers, or other parties; analyzes captured data and generated evidence to develop informal guidelines aimed at avoiding these harms; and disseminates those informal guidance to appropriate stakeholders.
  • Develop a Strategy for regulating use of AI in drug development by October 29, 2024 that would, at a minimum: (i) define the objectives, goals, and high-level principles required for appropriate regulation throughout each phase of drug development; (ii) identify areas where future rulemaking, guidance, or additional legislative authority may be necessary to implement such a regulatory system; (iv) identify the existing budget, resources, personnel, and potential for new public/private partnerships necessary for such a regulatory system; and (v) consider risks identified by the actions undertaken to implement section 4 of this order.

The EO also included a number of other provisions that would apply to the health and human sector, including for the National Institutes of Health (“NIH”) to prioritize grantmaking and cooperative agreement awards to promote innovation and competition.

To implement its policies, the EO creates the White House Artificial Intelligence Council, which will coordinate the activities of agencies across the federal government to ensure the effective formulation, development, communication, industry engagement related to, and timely implementation of AI-related policies (including policies set forth in the EO). Following the release of the EO, the Office of Management and Budget (“OMB”) released companion guidance to establish AI governance structures in federal agencies, advance responsible AI innovation, increase transparency, protect federal workers, and manage risks from government uses of AI.

Takeaways

The wide-ranging, long-awaited EO establishes a comprehensive vision for the responsible use and governance of AI. By establishing principles and including health care-specific directives, the Biden Administration has created an overarching framework that will have a significant impact on health care stakeholders’ development and deployment of AI systems and technologies. In addition, the EO offers a number of opportunities for government engagement and grant funding. As outlined, the various health and human sector provisions will be operationalized within the next several months. Stakeholders should expect to see agency-level developments and continue to track updates from the White House and various agencies (i.e., FDA, ONC, CMS, OCR).

Crowell will continue to provide analysis as federal agencies work to implement the policies described in the EO. For more information about the EO, please contact the professionals listed below, or your regular Crowell contact.

Last week, the Office for Civil Rights (“OCR”) issued two pieces of guidance on the privacy and security of protected health information (“PHI”) when using telehealth services. One of the documents is intended to help health care providers explain to patients, in plain language, the privacy and security risks of using remote communication technologies for telehealth (the “Provider Telehealth Guidance”). The other provides tips to patients on how to safeguard their PHI when using video apps and other technologies for telehealth (the “Patient Telehealth Guidance”).

Continue Reading OCR Issues Guidance to Providers and Patients on Telehealth Privacy and Security

Last week, Ranking Member Bill Cassidy (R-LA) of the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (“HELP”) issued two separate requests for information (“RFIs”) asking for stakeholder feedback on artificial intelligence (“AI”) and health data privacy policy issues to identify current challenges and receive recommendations to inform potential legislation.  With deadlines set for the end of September, each RFI provides a short window for organizations to submit comments.

Continue Reading Senate HELP Committee Ranking Member Requests Stakeholder Feedback on AI and Health Data Privacy and Security Policies

On August 19, 2023, the World Health Organization (“WHO”) announced a new initiative to operationalize the implementation of the Global Strategy on Digital Health 2020-2025 and to further enable digital health system transformation. The Global Initiative on Digital Health (“GIDH”) is a WHO managed network of stakeholders organized to facilitate the implementation of WHO norms and standards for digital health system transformation and to enable a global ecosystem to promote country capacity and strengthen international cooperation in digital health. The GIDH aims to amplify recent and past gains in global digital health while strengthening mutual accountability to enhance the impact of future investments.

Continue Reading WHO Announces Global Initiative Focused on Digital Health

The end of the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE) has pushed government benefit programs to reassess the use of their data that will ultimately improve access to health care benefits and streamline their processes to provide health and social services. With the end of pandemic-era policies like continuous enrollment, beneficiaries have been losing coverage while states face challenges reviewing Medicaid eligibility and may benefit from data sharing across government programs. Prior to the end of the PHE, KFF estimated that between 8 million and 24 million beneficiaries would be disenrolled. As of August 23, close to 5.4 million Medicaid beneficiaries have been disenrolled; and 74% of disenrollees have had their coverage terminated due to procedural reasons (e.g. changed addresses, did not receive a form, or did not have enough information about the renewal process).[i] This means that individuals are disenrolled because they did not complete the renewal process within a specific time frame or the state has outdated contact information.

Continue Reading Medicaid Redetermination Flexibilities and Data Sharing Under HIPAA

On June 21, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (“CMS”) issued a proposed notice with comment period outlining a transitional Medicare coverage pathway for emerging technologies through the national coverage determination (“NCD”) process in addition to several guidance documents that describe CMS’ approach to coverage reviews and evidence development, including the National Coverage Analysis Evidence Review and Clinical Endpoints Guidance: Knee Osteoarthritis.

Continue Reading CMS Proposes Transitional Medicare Coverage Pathway for Emerging Technologies